Motion C1
Structure of a Socialist Federation
Preamble
We note that:
Activists across hundreds of grassroots groups were brought together by the promise of Your Party.
The UK organised left is fragmented and isolated.
Your Party has hemorrhaged support, its members disenfranchised and expelled, and the bureaucracy maintains a tight grip on its infrastructure.
Fascism, climate and ecological collapse, economic crisis, poverty and insecurity, and authoritarianism are growing rapidly.
We believe that:
The world will not wait for us, so we must not wait.
Our circumstances require joint action, education and defence, and an active radical organisation led by the grassroots.
A network alone can connect people, but it cannot carry political responsibility – connection is not the same as coordination.
Without structure, decisions cannot be held, accountability weakens, and momentum fragments.
We require a unitary, mass, working class, socialist party to transform society.
In spite of urgency, such a party cannot be born, or achieve its aim, without a coherent programme.
This programme must be democratically and collectively formed by the working class in struggle.
To build it, we should aim to unite all socialist tendencies and organisations within a Socialist Federation.
Once the programme and structure of the unitary party is formed, the party may be launched by a decision of the membership.
Urgency is a correct instinct – we cannot miss the opportunity for socialism when it arrives.
Caution is a correct instinct – a vehicle without a sturdy chassis will crumble upon impact.
The majority of recent attempts to build a new mass workers party have collapsed along the same fault line: the accumulation of unelected power and the erosion of democracy, preventing the class from acquiring the experience to liberate itself.
Strict democratic safeguards are required precisely because they are the tools we must learn to wield in a socialist transition and future society.
This is not only a problem caused by individuals, but also by structural deficiencies – and these must be addressed from the outset.
Our movement must continue regardless of any individual or office. Therefore our practices must be structural and written, not reliant on goodwill or trust.
The only defence our class has against the tyranny of capital is our capacity to organise in great numbers, not in the following of great leaders.
To achieve this, we must root ourselves in working class community organising, listening and electoral agitation, with links to pre-existing class organisations such as unions, campaigns & the organised left.
Nevertheless, we must honestly acknowledge the democratic and political failures of these organisations, and raise the bar to empower our class to unite behind a socialist programme.
These failures have systematically broken trust, which must be rebuilt through practice, not promises, through radical honesty, transparency and action.
We must attempt to prefigure classlessness within our own institutions, ensuring elected delegates or officers are instantly recallable and never shielded from those whose interests they serve.
We must acknowledge that our class is suffering and depoliticised, struggling to make ends meet, meaning each of us has a material barrier that must be acknowledged and collectively mitigated.
This means we must provide mutual aid, defence, and solidarity; but also culture, events and projects – both “bread and roses”.
Community life has been broken by decades of neoliberalism and the regression to the capitalist normality of rampant inequality and consolidation of wealth.
Only through the combination of radical democracy and mutual aid will we reinvigorate working class socialist politics - we must prove our class solidarity, not merely profess it.
Resolution
We resolve to found the Socialist Federation according to the following provisions.
I. Form
A federation of organisations / association of members registered with the electoral commission.
Its binding documents will be: Political Statement, Constitution, Rules.
The Political Statement will be formulated from the initial platform proposals adopted at this conference.
Model Documentation will be provided for constituent organisations and meetings prior to the founding congress.
The Constitution, Rules & Model Documentation will be provided for constituent organisations and meetings, based on principles and provisions in this proposal.
No document in the Federation can contradict the binding documents.
Compositing choice C1.3
Composite (James Kulmer, Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau)
To be taken to a counterposed vote between OPTION 1 and OPTION 2.
OPTION 1 - Leave Blank, Renumber As Required
Proposer: Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau
Action: Leave the space indicated by the box marked “Choice C1.3” blank, and renumber sections as required.
Drafting Note: This choice also entails the deletion of the second sentence in Section XI Clause 1.
OPTION 2 - Include Section II, Renumber As Required
Proposer: James Kulmer
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.3”, renumber sections as necessary.
II. Values
1. A Values Statement will also be drafted as a federal binding document. The Values Statement will include and elaborate the following principles: a) Freedoms: Association, Speech, Choice, Information, Representation;
b) Balances: Fair & Non-Arbitrary Representation, Staff Serve Members, Mutual Accountability, Reciprocal & Redistributative Resourcing, Autonomy & Independence;
c) Rights: Majority Decisions & Minority Protections, Universal Suffrage & Participation, One Member One Vote One Representative, Proportional Representation, Deliberation Over Atomisation;
d) Values: Dignity, Honesty, Solidarity, Accountability, Inclusion, Democracy, Transparency;
e) Ethics: Liberation and Equality, Anti-fascism, Anti-war, Internationalism, Fighting Hate and Division, Zero Tolerance of Abuse, Mandatory Accessibility, Abolish Capitalism & Establish Socialism, Operating Within Planetary Boundaries
III. Purpose
To maintain the disregarded grassroots connections and networks built around the founding of Your Party.
To share information and material resources between our members and organisations.
To facilitate joint action, education and defence to combat the far-right, climate breakdown and the capitalist state.
To be an active campaigning body, including electoral & non-electoral work.
To hear, empower and organise our class nationally and internationally, to inform our policies and electoral strategies.
To reinvigorate grassroots democracy in discourse and practice.
To welcome all socialist tendencies, to constructively debate and respectfully disagree, to build real unity in action without the false unity of silence.
To provide a safeguarded democratic arena, for deciding joint action & designing the structure and programme of a future mass working class unitary party for a socialist transformation of society.
IV. Membership
Open to any socialist individual or group who accepts the Federation’s Statements, respects its Articles, and abides by its Rules.
Dual membership is explicitly permitted for organisations aligned with the Federation’s Statements.
Membership is obtained by individual application or group affiliation, with membership numbers allocated immediately, and cards as soon as possible.
Membership grants full participation rights, consisting of voting & speaking rights, nomination for any position & submission of business to any Federal body by the appropriate routes.
Compositing choice C1.4
Composite (James Kulmer, Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau)
To be taken to a counterposed vote between OPTION 1 and OPTION 2.
OPTION 1 - Mandatory Statutory Alignment
Proposer: James Kulmer
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.4”.
5. Statutory Alignment (the process of aligning the internal processes of a group with the Federation’s stipulated requirements) is required of any group integrating by affiliation within a certain timeframe.
OPTION 2 - Optional Statutory Alignment
Proposer: Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.4”.
5. Statutory Alignment (the process of aligning the internal processes of a group with the Federation’s stipulated requirements) is encouraged but not required of any group integrating by affiliation.
V. Branches
Branches are geographically based autonomous groups organised around residency or occupation.
They can be self-organised and registered by Federation members, or integrated by successful application to affiliate. Examples include: grassroots groups including proto-branches, student societies, workplace groups; and branches of unions, parties and campaign groups.
Joining a Branch is an active decision of each member, and Branch membership will not be allocated in any circumstance except through integration by affiliation.
Members may be in multiple Branches, provided this is transparently reported, and they do not stand in multiple Branch delegate elections, or hold positions in multiple Branches simultaneously.
VI. Associations
Branches may jointly form and register Associations, which are themselves Federations in miniature – fully autonomous and self-governing.
The Federation itself is the single highest Association. A Branch is an Association of Members. They operate similarly by design, to ensure participation at any level is not contingent or arbitrary.
Associations may form higher Associations with other Branches and/or Associations. The constituent Branches and Associations making up a higher Association are referred to as its “Units”.
Whilst part of an Association, its Units and Members are expected not to obstruct collective decisions made by the Association.
A Branch / Association can only be part of one Association at a time, but may form networks with any number of others. Leaving an Association does not require permission. Joining one is by application.
Together, these provisions allow the Federation to launch now, and build its internal structure voluntarily and autonomously as it grows.
Each Association will maintain a proxy “At-Large” branch for members in no Branch, to obtain delegates and submit business.
VII. Assemblies
Each Association maintains a Delegate Assembly, of delegates apportioned to its units in proportion to their membership, transparently accounting for overlaps by appropriate reduction if required.
The Federation’s Delegate Assembly is the Federal Congress. The Delegate Assembly of a Branch is a Branch Meeting.
An Association’s Delegate Assembly is its sovereign body, only subordinate to higher Association’s Delegate Assemblies. It is sovereign over its own business, binding documentation, and offices.
Units of an Association do not directly elect delegations and submit nominations / business to higher Delegate Assemblies, but via their Delegate Assembly.
Every Delegate Assembly has a fixed term, after which all delegations and positions are re-elected. A maximum number of delegates will be set each term, with a fixed member-to-delegate ratio. Units under the ratio may form temporary Associations with other Units to obtain a joint delegation.
VIII. Offices
Every Association maintains the same Separation of Powers in three Offices: Executive, Secretariat and Judiciary. They are simultaneously and separately elected by and subordinate to its Assembly, with the same term length. For Branches an Office can be a single Officer, for Associations they are Committees.
They are each subordinate to their Assembly, but hold no power over each other. They may meet together or separately by mutual consent. They may not overlap. The Standing Orders of each Office are the property of the Assembly, not the Office.
The Executive holds the powers of the Assembly, less those assigned to the other 2 Offices. It may not amend or repeal any Association’s binding documents, or overturn any Delegate Assembly’s decisions. It is the political leadership of the Association, responsible for finances, education, media, and coordination.
The Secretariat manages the credentials and business of the Delegate Assembly, including solicitation, publication and compositing. It also acts as a membership and affiliation office. The agenda is the property of the Assembly, but it may categorise and rate business by plurality, popularity, (ecological) necessity and (future) impact when publishing submissions ahead of a session.
The Judiciary acts as a mediation, complaints, appeals, and safeguarding office for the Association. It appoints a returning officer to oversee Assembly elections, and a named safeguarding contact. It may audit the Executive and Secretariat.
A Delegate Assembly may establish a Commission, a temporary and goal-oriented Office elected by, mandated by, and subordinate to the Assembly that established it. In a Branch they are typically known as Working Groups.
IX. Councils
An Association’s Units’ Offices of a given type jointly form an Officers’ Council.
It may meet informally to communicate, or formally to act in emergencies. A quorum is established if the combined mandate of the Officers present represents a majority of the Association’s members.
A quorate Council meeting may resolve to send emergency business via an advocate (an observer who can argue for that business without a vote) to its corresponding Higher Office, or in extreme cases temporarily suspend and elect an interim replacement for an Officer in that Higher Office, which will be upheld or repealed only by the Association’s Delegate Assembly.
Council members may observe non-confidential portions of Higher Office meetings, and may invite observers from Higher Offices.
X. Caucuses
Members of an Association may organise themselves into a Caucus, which may maintain its own structure, networks, publications, membership and discipline. It may represent a minority political platform, oppressed group, or shared interest.
An existing organisation may apply to affiliate and integrate as a Caucus, granting membership in the same way as Branch integration.
It may operate informally, but it (or one of its sub-divisions) may apply to formally register with an Association’s Secretariat. Registration criteria include verifying geographical distribution, majority Association membership and minority status.
Registration invokes regular dues, and membership list submission when needed; and grants the right to submit business to & observe the Association’s Delegate Assembly via an advocate, be listed / linked in the Federation’s directory, submit nominations for Office or Commission positions, and be listed on ballot papers.
To submit business via an advocate, the Caucus must demonstrate upon submission they have enough members that they would be apportioned a delegate were they a unit. Caucuses may form temporary Associations to jointly submit and elect an advocate / observer if desired or needed.
Compositing choice C1.7
Composite (James Kulmer, Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau)
To be taken to a counterposed vote between OPTION 1 and OPTION 2.
OPTION 1 - General Caucusing without Votes & Quotas
Proposer: James Kulmer
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.7”.
6. Caucus registration ensures that oppressed people have a space from which to organise to ensure that unites our class in collective struggle for liberation from all oppressions.
7. A Caucus may be recognised as a Liberation Caucus by an Assembly, representing a marginalised or oppressed group, which waives all dues. Each Liberation Caucus is autonomously self-organised by oppressed or marginalised groups and are responsible to their members.
OPTION 2 - Liberation Caucuses as a Special Case with Votes & Quotas
Proposer: Raz O’Connor
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.7”.
6. Liberation Caucuses are constitutionally established for (in no particular order) 1. LGBT+ members, 2. Disabled members, 3. Global Majority members, 4. Women members, 5. Young Members (under 30). There are no dues for Liberation Caucuses.
7. Each Liberation Caucus forms a delegated body alongside each non-Branch Association, sends delegates with voting rights to the Association’s Assembly, and each non-Branch Executive holds a reserved seat per Liberation Caucus, each elected separately by the Assembly, at the same time, with the same term.
Compositing choice C1.8
Composite (James Kulmer, Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau)
To be taken to a counterposed vote between OPTION 1 and OPTION 2.
OPTION 1 - Leave Blank, Renumber As Required
Proposer: Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau
Action: Leave the space indicated by the box marked “Choice C1.8” blank, and renumber sections as required.
Drafting Note: This option also entails the deletion of Section XVI Clause 1.5, and the words “and Civic Body” from Section XVI Clause 1.6.
OPTION 2 - Include Section XI, Renumber As Necessary
Proposer: James Kulmer
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.8, renumber sections as required.
XI. Civic Body
1. A Civic Body will be tasked with rebuilding communal life and creating a pathway for the un-politicised into socialist politics. Participation will be contingent on acceptance of the Federation’s Values Statement only.
2. Federation members will be encouraged to participate to foster a socialist culture, and likewise Civic Body members will be encouraged to register as Socialist Federation members.
3. It will be formally independent from the Federation and future party — embodied in a separate legal entity such as a Community Interest Company or Co-operative. 4. Its assets will be placed beyond the reach of any single Federation body, and may disaffiliate from the Federation in the event of a repeat of Your Party’s bureaucratic capture.
5. Its remit includes activities such as: social centres, youth clubs, collective childcare, sports / gym activities, coffee mornings, school breakfast clubs, canteens, art / music events, walking groups, mindfulness sessions, group mental health support.
XII. Policy
An Association’s Policy is only ever adopted by a resolution of a Delegate Assembly. Business (motions, amendments) is submitted in the first instance either by Members to a Branch / Caucus which submits it higher, or by an Office or Commission of the Association.
Members may use asynchronous online tools as well as meetings to develop proposals for submission in this democratic process.
Composites only go forward with the unanimous consent of all proposers comprising the composited motion or amendment. Compositing meeting minutes are published identically to Officer meetings.
Branches will be encouraged and empowered to hold regular (minimum quarterly, maximum annually): 4.1 Community forums, bringing together groups including grassroots organisers, mutual aid networks, youth representatives, trade unionists, faith communities, cultural groups and disability organisations. Contributions and feedback are transparently collated and published.
“Health-Checks” of its members, with its findings published. It will query governance efficacy, representational adequacy, power concentration, desired changes and safeguarding concerns. Proposed actions are recorded and revisited at the subsequent health-check meeting.
Associations are empowered to aggregate community forum and health-check findings to publish an annual report identifying patterns or persistent concerns.
XIII. Finances
Dues are paid by a member to the Branches they are a member of. Branches pay dues and levies to Associations, and so on upwards towards the Federation, ensuring a bottom-up resourcing model.
Associations are mandated to redistribute dues by adjusting dues and levies towards the Federation’s average income once per term, reported in a financial report and resolved by the Assembly.
Branches will retain no less than 50% of their income (dues, donations). This percentage can only be amended by the Federal Congress.
The Federation will bound but not prescribe dues across its Branches, Associations and Caucuses. A Solidarity rate set at £1 per month initially will be mandated.
Corporate donations are prohibited by the constitution. Donations above a certain amount must be transparently recorded and auditable by members.
Once per term an Assembly will adopt a budget, apportioning funds to Offices and Commissions democratically.
An Office or Commission may enlist volunteers or staff if permitted by their mandate. No allocated wage or rate in the Federation may exceed the average worker’s wage in the relevant area.
XIV. Data
Branches hold their own membership lists and are only required to submit them to Associations for delegate apportionment. Likewise for Association submission to higher Associations.
The Rules’ Data Policy will describe 3 data categories: public, internal and sensitive.
Public data is accessible publicly, including a directory of Branches, Caucuses and Associations, and application / affiliation details.
Internal data is accessible by all Federation members, including all Assembly, Office and Commission minutes, Officer identities / contact details, and delegate / officer voting records.
Sensitive data is accessible on a case-by-case basis defined by the Federation’s rules, including membership information, unredacted minutes, safeguarding records, etc.
In return for Unit dues and membership lists, Associations reciprocate by providing platforms for networking and publications. This is a constitutional right to prevent arbitrary deplatforming.
XV. Safeguards
The minimum rules for all meetings, whose adoption is part of statutory alignment, will include provisions for the meeting to remove and challenge its chair, agenda and rules, with reasonable guardrails to prevent abuse.
A general principle will be that meeting decisions should always follow debate. Consensus may be sought, but objections must always prompt speeches and votes both in favour and against.
An Association’s Delegates, Officers and Commission positions are all instantly recallable, in the first instance by the Assembly that granted their mandate, but also by a petition whose collective signatures (members, groups) represent a collective decision of the Association.
All Assembly, Office and Commission minutes must be published within a week, redacted only where data protection or safeguarding requires it. Defeated minority positions (20%) must be recorded.
Any non-Branch Delegate Assembly must accept Alternates at a fixed delegate-to-alternate ratio, who attend as observers ready to be empowered by the Assembly to substitute for a delegate if absent.
A Secretariat Officer may not facilitate compositing or judgement of their own submissions to their Assembly. Likewise a returning officer may not be a candidate in the election they facilitate.
The Rules’ Accessibility Policy will require documentation to be in plain language where possible, and accompanied by an explainer if not. It will also include accessibility as a right, not a priority.
An Association’s Secretariat may apply “levelling tests” to any business that materially changes its direction, affects who can participate, or commits substantial shared resources, asking whether it raises or lowers barriers, how it affects ease of participation, and whether it is expressed in plain language. It may publish their findings alongside the published business, for delegates to consider.
The Rules’ Safeguarding Policy will guarantee concerns are acknowledged in a given timeframe, and all parties are informed of the timeline and process. Safeguarding training will be centrally provided.
XVI. Initial Strategy
The Founding Congress will: 1.1 Establish the Founding Members, Branches, Associations and Caucuses of the Federation, together with elections for any initial sitting bodies (Offices & Commissions).
Debate, amend and adopt the binding documents of the Federation.
Establish (either there or within a defined timeframe by electing an interim steering group), separate National Associations for Scotland, Wales, England, and if desired, Ireland, independently organised by comrade members from each Nation.
Establish a Federal Development Commission, tasked with providing materials, resources, training and assistance to Members to found and formalise their Branches / Caucuses / Associations, and achieve statutory alignment in a given timescale. It may establish an Empowerment Fund to empower members to overcome material challenges.
Establish a Federal Commons Commission mandated to found and subsequently liaise with the Civic Body to maintain a close relationship. The Commission will operate as interim stewards, and facilitate an election for its stewards, which are coordinators, not political leaders.
Establish a Federal Listening Commission, mandated to coordinate listening campaigns within the Federation and Civic Body, collating and publishing the results transparently, and formulating policy proposals based on them to take to the Federal Congress.
The pace of building is set by what is actually built, not by any external deadlines. No unit will be required to move faster than its members are ready to unless required by this resolution, and similarly, no unit requires permission to begin building.
Amendments & compositing choices 15
-
Amendment C1.1
Terry Conway
Insert at the end of point 13 in the Preamble:
By democracy we mean collective decision making taken after debate that everyone is able to participate in rather than answering closed questions. To achieve this it is key that meetings are held in accessible venues and are hybrid.
-
Amendment C1.2 · Clarifying Edits
James Kulmer
Amendment
Preamble
A clarifying edit, given ambiguity of intent as drafted.
In Section I Form, replace point 6 with:
The binding documents of constituent organisations within the Federation are the property of each such organisation, but should not contradict the binding documents of the Federation.
And in Section IX Civic Body, in both points 3 and 4, replace “will” with “could”.
-
Compositing choice C1.3
Composite (James Kulmer, Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau)
To be taken to a counterposed vote between OPTION 1 and OPTION 2.
OPTION 1 - Leave Blank, Renumber As Required
Proposer: Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau
Action: Leave the space indicated by the box marked “Choice C1.3” blank, and renumber sections as required.
Drafting Note: This choice also entails the deletion of the second sentence in Section XI Clause 1.
OPTION 2 - Include Section II, Renumber As Required
Proposer: James Kulmer
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.3”, renumber sections as necessary.
II. Values
1. A Values Statement will also be drafted as a federal binding document. The Values Statement will include and elaborate the following principles: a) Freedoms: Association, Speech, Choice, Information, Representation;
b) Balances: Fair & Non-Arbitrary Representation, Staff Serve Members, Mutual Accountability, Reciprocal & Redistributative Resourcing, Autonomy & Independence;
c) Rights: Majority Decisions & Minority Protections, Universal Suffrage & Participation, One Member One Vote One Representative, Proportional Representation, Deliberation Over Atomisation;
d) Values: Dignity, Honesty, Solidarity, Accountability, Inclusion, Democracy, Transparency;
e) Ethics: Liberation and Equality, Anti-fascism, Anti-war, Internationalism, Fighting Hate and Division, Zero Tolerance of Abuse, Mandatory Accessibility, Abolish Capitalism & Establish Socialism, Operating Within Planetary Boundaries
-
Compositing choice C1.4
Composite (James Kulmer, Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau)
To be taken to a counterposed vote between OPTION 1 and OPTION 2.
OPTION 1 - Mandatory Statutory Alignment
Proposer: James Kulmer
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.4”.
5. Statutory Alignment (the process of aligning the internal processes of a group with the Federation’s stipulated requirements) is required of any group integrating by affiliation within a certain timeframe.
OPTION 2 - Optional Statutory Alignment
Proposer: Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.4”.
5. Statutory Alignment (the process of aligning the internal processes of a group with the Federation’s stipulated requirements) is encouraged but not required of any group integrating by affiliation.
-
Amendment C1.5 · Ballot Methods for Assembly Elections
John Urquhart
Insertion point: VIII.5 (Offices — Judiciary), as new clause 6 under the returning-officer mandate
Type: New clause
Attaches to: "It appoints a returning officer to oversee Assembly elections" — the returning officer exists but no ballot method is named anywhere in v4.2, leaving elections open to first-past-the-post by default.
Amendment text (to insert):
6. The returning officer appointed under Clause 5 of this section shall conduct all Assembly elections by the following methods:
6.1 Where a single Office, position, or seat is contested, the ballot shall use the Schulze method: a ranked preferential method in which every candidate is compared against every other by the full set of preferences expressed, producing a result that reflects the broadest acceptable choice of the Assembly and resists tactical voting.
6.2 Where two or more seats are contested in the same election — including the election of any multi-member Office Committee — the ballot shall use the Single Transferable Vote with Meek's method: a proportional, quota-based count in which surplus votes transfer according to current elected weights, keeping the result coherent as candidates are elected or excluded.
6.3 The returning officer shall publish the full preference data and the step-by-step count alongside the result, as internal data under Section XIV, within one week of the election result being declared.
-
Amendment C1.6
Susan Pashkoff
Add: “that oppressed people have a space from which to organise to ensure”.
General comment: there is a confusion between caucuses and factions. These must be separated out. Factions cover affiliated groups, they can be minority political platforms, or groups that share a common interest.
Point 1
Remove: any references to a minority political platform or a shared interest in the paragraph as this is not a faction or a fraction.
Point 6 (Within Option 1)
Remove: “minority positions and identities always have a formal route to representation, contribution, and nomination in Assemblies, without altering the allocation of voting rights or elected mandates in the democratic process”.
Point 7 (Within Option 1)
Remove: “Each Secretariat must monitor the makeup of Assemblies, Offices & Commissions in relation to Liberation Caucus membership, and periodically submit this to a Federal Minority Representation Commission, which is empowered to consult, report and intervene in cases of persistent disproportionality of representation.”
Add after “dues”: “Each Liberation Caucus is autonomously self-organised by oppressed or marginalised groups and are responsible to their members.”
-
Compositing choice C1.7
Composite (James Kulmer, Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau)
To be taken to a counterposed vote between OPTION 1 and OPTION 2.
OPTION 1 - General Caucusing without Votes & Quotas
Proposer: James Kulmer
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.7”.
6. Caucus registration ensures that oppressed people have a space from which to organise to ensure that unites our class in collective struggle for liberation from all oppressions.
7. A Caucus may be recognised as a Liberation Caucus by an Assembly, representing a marginalised or oppressed group, which waives all dues. Each Liberation Caucus is autonomously self-organised by oppressed or marginalised groups and are responsible to their members.
OPTION 2 - Liberation Caucuses as a Special Case with Votes & Quotas
Proposer: Raz O’Connor
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.7”.
6. Liberation Caucuses are constitutionally established for (in no particular order) 1. LGBT+ members, 2. Disabled members, 3. Global Majority members, 4. Women members, 5. Young Members (under 30). There are no dues for Liberation Caucuses.
7. Each Liberation Caucus forms a delegated body alongside each non-Branch Association, sends delegates with voting rights to the Association’s Assembly, and each non-Branch Executive holds a reserved seat per Liberation Caucus, each elected separately by the Assembly, at the same time, with the same term.
-
Compositing choice C1.8
Composite (James Kulmer, Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau)
To be taken to a counterposed vote between OPTION 1 and OPTION 2.
OPTION 1 - Leave Blank, Renumber As Required
Proposer: Joseph “Raz” O’Connor Meldau
Action: Leave the space indicated by the box marked “Choice C1.8” blank, and renumber sections as required.
Drafting Note: This option also entails the deletion of Section XVI Clause 1.5, and the words “and Civic Body” from Section XVI Clause 1.6.
OPTION 2 - Include Section XI, Renumber As Necessary
Proposer: James Kulmer
Action: Insert the below text at the box marked “Choice C1.8, renumber sections as required.
XI. Civic Body
1. A Civic Body will be tasked with rebuilding communal life and creating a pathway for the un-politicised into socialist politics. Participation will be contingent on acceptance of the Federation’s Values Statement only.
2. Federation members will be encouraged to participate to foster a socialist culture, and likewise Civic Body members will be encouraged to register as Socialist Federation members.
3. It will be formally independent from the Federation and future party — embodied in a separate legal entity such as a Community Interest Company or Co-operative. 4. Its assets will be placed beyond the reach of any single Federation body, and may disaffiliate from the Federation in the event of a repeat of Your Party’s bureaucratic capture.
5. Its remit includes activities such as: social centres, youth clubs, collective childcare, sports / gym activities, coffee mornings, school breakfast clubs, canteens, art / music events, walking groups, mindfulness sessions, group mental health support.
-
Amendment C1.9 · Continuous Online Deliberation Feeding Assemblies
John Urquhart
Insertion point: XII.2 (as new clauses XII.3–XII.3.3; renumber existing XII.3–XII.5 as XII.4–XII.6)
Type: Insert after.
Attaches to: "Members may use asynchronous online tools as well as meetings to develop proposals for submission in this democratic process." — XII.2 affirms the tools but leaves what they must do unspecified.
Amendment text (to insert):
XII.3 The Secretariat will maintain a standing online deliberative space — accessible to all members of the Association — in which any business awaiting submission or currently submitted to an Assembly may be opened for ongoing asynchronous discussion. The Secretariat will publish a structured summary of the areas of convergence and divergence that have emerged from each such discussion alongside the business when it is distributed ahead of a session, in addition to any categorisation and rating it makes under Clause VIII.4.
XII.3.1 Standard deliberation. Business submitted by Members, Branches, Caucuses or Offices enters the standing space as soon as it is logged with the Secretariat. Members engage at their own pace. The Secretariat publishes a plain-language cluster summary — identifying lines of shared concern and lines of disagreement that have emerged, without attributing them to tendencies or named individuals — before that business appears on any Assembly agenda. Where a cluster summary reveals that a significant body of members share common concerns not yet represented by any existing Branch, Caucus or Association, the Secretariat will note this in its summary and the Assembly may direct the Federal Development Commission (or equivalent body) to follow up.
XII.3.2 Emergency deliberation. Where an Association's Office has failed to act on a matter that members consider urgent, any member may open an emergency deliberation in the standing space. If, after a published minimum period, the number of members who have actively participated in that deliberation meets or exceeds the threshold for a Branch delegate apportionment under VII.5, those participating members may collectively request, via the Secretariat, that the matter be placed before the Assembly as emergency business; or nominate an advocate to carry the matter to a Higher Office under IX.3; regardless of whether an Office has endorsed it. The Assembly receives and decides the matter under its ordinary delegate franchise.
XII.3.3 All deliberation in the standing space, on both tracks, is published on the Federation's own infrastructure and is readable by all members before any vote on the related business opens. No vote on business proceeds at an Assembly until the Secretariat has confirmed that the relevant deliberation period has closed and its cluster summary has been distributed.
(Renumber existing XII.3 through XII.5 as XII.4 through XII.6.)
-
Amendment C1.10 · Electoral Engagement
James Kulmer
Amendment
Preamble
Submitted as an amendment after composite production, due to authoring after the deadline.
Insert the following after Section XV Safeguards, renumber as necessary.
XVI. Electoral Engagement
A general principle of non-competition will be established between constituent organisations integrated as Branches or Caucuses within the Federation in relation to state elections (e.g. council, mayoral, parliamentary etc).
When a state election is announced, all groups with members within the relevant constituency have the right to form an Election Committee, comprising instantly recallable elected delegates from those groups in proportion to their membership residing or working in the constituency.
If the Committee resolves to stand a candidate, it will be responsible for facilitating an Open Selection process open to all such relevant members and groups for nomination and selection.
The Election Committee will be reconstituted & re-elected as an Accountability Committee for the term of an elected officeholder’s term.
It is responsible for coordination and communication between the officeholder and those groups delegated to the committee, and ensuring compliance with relevant policies whilst in office.
-
Amendment C1.11 · Vectoral Programme
Graham Jones
Under XVI. Initial Strategy, replace 1.6 with the following:
1.6 Establish a Living Programme Commission mandated to ensure ongoing democratic programme development, including coordinating listening campaigns and workers’ inquiries within the Federation and Civic Body, collating and publishing the results transparently, and feeding this information into proposals to be brought to the Federal Congress for wider membership deliberation. The programme will adopt the four-level form set out in the Interim Platform.
-
Amendment C1.12 · Swarm Organising
Graham Jones
In section XVI. ‘Initial Strategy’, under point 1.4 insert the following between the first and second sentences:
This is to include the development of a condensed programme and related digital infrastructure for training purposes, along with processes to obtain materials (photographs and videos) of local group actions, as necessitated by the Interim Platform.
-
Amendment C1.13
Marcus Halaby
DELETE:
V. Branches
VI. Associations
VII. Assemblies
VIII. Offices
IX. Councils
XI. Civic Body
XII. Policy
XVI. Initial Strategy
REPLACE WITH:
V. Branches
Branches are the basic groups in which members work and organise.
They can be based in a geographical area or a workplace.
Branches are self-governing.
VI. Regional and national committees
Branches in a given region may convene a committee of representatives to coordinate activity across their region and nation.
VII. Industrial committees
Workplace branches in a given industrial sector may convene a committee of representatives to coordinate activity across their industry
VIII. Federal Council
Each branch, each regional, national and industrial committee and each caucus of members of oppressed groups sends a delegate to a monthly meeting of the Federal Council.
The Federal Council will serve as the sovereign body of the Socialist Federation.
The Federal Council will manage national matters on behalf of the Socialist Federation including fundraising and finance, legal and regulatory compliance, branding, national publicity and media, templates for leaflets, website and social media, education and training, internal communications, national campaigns, accessibility and security, safeguarding, disputes and other matters as necessary including policy development.
IX. Executive Committee
The Federal Council may elect from its number a recallable Executive Committee to coordinate business between Federal Council meetings.
XI. Safeguarding Commission
The Founding Congress elects a Safeguarding Commission comprising five members who may not be members of the Federal Council or Executive Committee and who will hold the behaviour of members of the council and the committee to account, investigating complaints of misconduct and abuse.
The Safeguarding Commission is to be re-elected annually by the National Congress
XII. Beyond Federalism
At least every two years the Federal Council will convene a National Congress.
This could comprise delegates from branches, sections and affiliates, or (if numbers and finances permit) a conference of the entire membership.
If Congress is satisfied that the organisation has achieved the necessary scale, maturity, political alignment and mutual trust to create a unitary organisation, its Conference will elect a Central National Council superseding the Federal Council, bringing the initial federal phase to an end and establishing a democratic and unitary national organisation.
-
Amendment C1.14 · What Sort Of Legal Entity Are We Setting Up?
Phil Pope
Add to Section I Form:
Note: This amendment is contingent on Amendment C1.13 passing, and will fall otherwise.
Making the right decision about what sort of legal entity the organisation is will greatly speed up our work. Many political parties are constituted as unincorporated associations but this causes legal obstacles with owning assets, agreeing contracts, employing staff, holding data, opening bank accounts etc. Because of this they set up a limited company to carry out these functions on behalf of the party. This can undermine the democracy of the unincorporated association by giving a great deal of control to another legal entity. It is much better to constitute the party as a company limited by guarantee so that it can be both democratically controlled by the membership and at the same time have full control of its own assets.
The composite proposal is far too long and detailed to be given proper consideration by this meeting. Therefore my proposal is to amend the composite if Marcus Halaby’s amendment passes, by the following addition.
The organisation will be registered as a company limited by guarantee. The delegates to the Federal Council will constitute the membership. The elected National Executive Committee will constitute the trustees of the company.
-
Amendment C1.15
Phil Pope
Add to Section IX Executive Committee:
Note: This amendment is contingent on Amendment C1.13 passing, and will fall otherwise.
The next essential step is to get a democratically elected team of people working together as an Executive Committee to start producing campaigns and building organisation capacity. Agreeing a method of election today will speed this process up.
The composite proposal is far too long and detailed to be given proper consideration by this meeting. Therefore my proposal is to amend the composite if Marcus Halaby’s amendment passes, by the following addition.
The election of the Executive Committee will be conducted by Single Transferable Vote (Scottish Rules) using a third-party online platform to ensure transparency and fairness e.g. Opavote or RCV123.
The Executive Committee should not be overly large - between 5 and 11 people is sufficient to represent a broad range of opinion but to work efficiently. As the number of delegates increases the Federal Council can choose to increase the size of the Executive Committee to the maximum of 11 people. If specific expertise is needed the Executive Committee can ask for help from supporters outside the committee.
This election should be competitive and not just elect all or nearly all the people who stand. A contested election gives the winning candidates the democratic legitimacy to make decisions and provide leadership to the organisation.